Logitech G3 Laser Mouse ( 931691-0403 )

Logitech G3 Laser Mouse ( 931691-0403 )

Introduction:

The gaming mouse market has certainly expanded quite a bit in the past few years; a little while ago, Razer was probably the only producers of "gaming-grade" mice, but with the entry of Logitech into the arena in the last half of 2005, things have gotten more interesting. The gaming mouse market is still very much a niche affair, as most people won't (or don't) care about what mouse they use, but for the hardcore gamers out there, the choice in mice is perhaps almost as important as the choice in videocard.

With the advent of laser tracking for mice, the gaming mice have only gotten better; however, laser tracking is not enough to define a gaming mouse nowadays - it must have a bevy of other gamer-friendly features, such as on-the-fly DPI adjustment, and extra buttons, among other things. Logitech has included many of these features on their first two gaming mice, the wireless G7 and the wired G5. However, the Razer Copperhead still had them beat out in one area - it was ambidextrous, while the G7 and G5 were strictly only for right-handed users, leaving lefties feeling left out. (How's that for overuse of a word?)

With the recent release of the MX610, it seems that Logitech is moving towards supporting left-handed users more. Following that, they've released the gaming-grade G3 Laser Mouse, which is an ambidextrous unit intended to round out their gaming mice lineup, and to provide direct competition to the Razer Copperhead that we reviewed earlier. Is the G3 a deserving member of Logitech's gaming lineup?

how about check out this great gaming keyboard?

 
Ideazon ZBoard Age of Empires III KeySet...

Specifications:

The G3 features many of the same specs as the previous G7/G5 mice, and apparently uses the same 2000 dpi laser engine as the two. It's a wired mouse, like the G5 and Razer Copperhead, so there's no worry about batteries, and the typical sleep mode of mice has been disabled/removed on the G3, so there's no lag time when moving the mouse from a resting position.

Full list of specifications.

The G3's USB report rate is 500 Hz, less than the 1000 Hz offered by the Razer Copperhead, but the same as on the G7/G5; when testing the G7 at 500 Hz I found no lag problems, but that depends on whether you can tell the difference between 2 ms and 1 ms. Sensitivity switching (changing of the DPI) is also supported in hardware, meaning that you can switch between two sensitivity levels before installing any drivers. Curiously, the G3 doesn't support 2000 dpi unless you install the drivers, and can only switch between 1600 and 800 DPI before drivers. The G7 and G5 both supported 2000/800/400 DPI before driver installation, so I'm wondering if this feature was intentionally crippled on the G3 in order to segregate the market. In any event, SetPoint is a useful driver utility; installing it also allows you to tailor the DPI settings to your liking.

The G3 comes in a smaller-than-usual package, which is good for the environment but may not be good for selling, as customers would probably notice a bigger, flashier box; however this packaging might not be final since this was a review sample. I applaud smaller packaging though, since it's worked well for games - we don't need gigantic boxes for fist-sized products. Inside, the contents were similarly spartan; only the G3 mouse and an installation guide were included - a CD with the SetPoint drivers was not provided!

Considering that SetPoint is needed for the G3 to perform at its advertised 2000 DPI rate, the exclusion of a driver CD to save on costs may not have been a good idea; The download of SetPoint is over 46 MB, and while that's no trouble for someone with a decent Internet connection, it can still be annoying. As mentioned before, this was a review sample so the final package might include a driver CD.

The shape of the G3 is ambidextrous, and resembles a standard three-button wheel mouse's shape, but also looks like a gamer's mouse, with its dark colour scheme of black and red. Part of the mouse body is covered in a glossy striped-onyx pattern, while the rest is black with red accents. However, most of the mouse isn't glossy, as a very smooth surface isn't ideal for a mouse body or its grips, since it tends to collect sweat/gunk, as was observed on the original G7 mouse. The sides of the G3 are made of a tough, textured grip surface Logitech calls DryGrip - it feels nice to hold and actually does work better to keep your hand less sweaty during extend gaming sessions. It's similar to the grip sides on some other Logitech mice, but is less smooth and provides more grip.

My initial impressions were thus very favourable for the G3 - right away it both looks and feels like a gamer's mouse, and not just another "pretty piece of hardware".

The G3 includes two extra buttons, one on each side of the mouse, for a total of six buttons, which includes the wheel button and sensitivity adjustment. This setup is similar to the Razer Copperhead's, but with only five buttons instead of the Copperhead's seven. It should be noted that there's no tilt wheel on the G3, unlike the G7/G5; I was definitely expecting a tilt wheel, since it's basically become a standard on high-end mice and can be useful in games or just regular desktop usage. This may be a problem for some who like to use their mouse for many functions or actions.

Unlike the G7/G5 mice, there aren't separate buttons for increasing and decreasing the sensitivity. Instead, there's a single sensitivity switch button; without any driver installation it serves to toggle between 1600 and 800 DPI for the mouse. If you choose to install SetPoint, you can set up to five different sensitivity level, and the sensitivity button will switch between them in a pyramidal fashion instead of a cyclic fashion. Allow me to explain - let's say you have three sensitivity levels, 2000, 1600 and 800 DPI - starting off at 800, the progression would be like this: 800, 1600, 2000, 1600, 800. Logitech claims this is done to prevent "any abrupt" change in tracking sensitivity. It should also be noted that there's no display on the mouse to indicate the current level of sensitivity, unlike on the G7/G5 mice.

Right away, one can see the limitation of such a system, if one regularly switches between the different sensitivity levels. If you only have two different levels, then having only one button is alright, and probably even better than having two separate ones, since you only need to toggle between the two. However, with more than two, the process described above could be tricky - if you're at 1600 DPI, you have to press the button three times to get down to 800 DPI. Many people will not regularly switch between the DPI settings, but since it's a highly-touted feature, it deserves some scrutiny. (The DPI switching is useful not only in games (eg. for sniping), but also for desktop work like image editing where sometimes you need to slow the cursor down for fine work - lowering the DPI while not changing any software settings effectively does this.)

Besides the sensitivity switcher, there's two extra buttons, one on each side of the mouse, arranged in a symmetrical fashion. By default, the buttons are configured as back and forward, with the button that's used by the right-handed thumb being "back", and the other "forward". Obviously, if you're left-handed, you can change these button assignments from within the SetPoint driver software. Back and forward functionality is the strongest argument for these extra buttons, and it's quite useful, both for web browsers and navigating folders in the OS.

While the thumb-side button is fairly easy to use, I found that the other side's button was a bit trickier - I had to press it just using the inside of my ring finger, about half-way up, since that's where the button lies under. It's a bit awkward, and at first, I found myself accidentally pressing this button since I wasn't used to one being there - this is the downside of the mouse being ambidextrous, as it can't be tailored to just a right or left-handed user. It does take some time to get used to, but after a few days of use I got used to it.

The bottom of the mouse has three large feet to keep friction low. This, combined with the low weight made the G3 very easy to move - combined with a good mousepad, this should be one of the slickest mice to use. This, combined with the good "feel" of it makes it comfortable to use. In the last picture, I've included a comparison with some other Logitech mice. The smallest one is the V400 Cordless Notebook Mouse that I reviewed earlier, while the other two are the MX1000 and G7 Laser Cordless. As you can see, the G3 is pretty much in the middle in terms of size, and is comparable to an average mouse.

Installation:

Basic installation is easy - you just plug the mouse into your PC, and it's auto-detected like any other USB device. You don't need to install SetPoint, but if you want to get all the functionality out of the G3 Laser Mouse, then you have to. This is especially important, since for some reason, if you want to get 2000 DPI sensitivity you need to have SetPoint installed. The download of SetPoint 3.01, the latest version, is over 46 MB, which shouldn't be a problem on most Internet connections nowadays, but it's still kind of large for mouse software. Logitech should have considered including a driver CD, but I'm guessing they thought that the kinds of people who'd buy this mouse are also the kinds who have high-speed connections.

After installing, you'll have to reboot. Once that's done, the mouse will be auto-detected by SetPoint, and the default options will be setup. The button options are pretty typical for a Logitech mouse; you can pretty much set each button to do a variety of things, but keeping them set as "Generic" buttons will allow them to be used in games as well as on the desktop. The default configuration works well, so I didn't bother to change it.

Movement options were pretty much standard as well - nothing fancy here. The game settings page allows you to configure how the mouse works in games, that is, whether custom mouse button settings should be kept when a game launches. Sometimes you won't want this, and instead will want the buttons to be generic buttons in games - SetPoint provides this functionality.

The sensitivity options allow you to set up to five levels between 400 and 2000 DPI, in increments of 50 DPI. Horizontal and vertical sensitivity can be set independently if for some reason you find one axis needs more sensitivity. You can also configure what games should have these settings. SetPoint, as always, is a good mouse control software package, provides good functionality, and is recommended if you want to customize your mouse.

Testing:

I tested the G3 a lot in gaming (mostly CS: Source, Guild Wars and Oblivion), and also logged a lot of usage time with it on the desktop, doing regular tasks like web-browsing, image editing and just general desktop usage. Overall, I'm very impressed with its performance and feel, and only have a few reservations. First, I'll start with the good.

The mouse is very responsive, accurate and precise. Even without using SetPoint (and having the G3 limited to 1600 DPI), it was plenty accurate; being able to toggle between 1600 and 800 DPI was quite useful, but the addition SetPoint, which allowed for 2000 DPI sensitivity made it all the more better. Why SetPoint was needed for 2000 DPI is beyond me.

The mouse was also very comfortable to use. The textured side grips (called DryGrip by Logitech) provided a unique and nice feel that made holding on to the mouse not feel slippery at all. It actually did work to help alleviate the problems of sweat during long gaming sessions. The shape is also very nice for an ambidextrous mouse, and I think righties and lefties should be satisfied.

All the buttons also provided nice, sharp tactile feedback - this includes the wheel button and the two extra side buttons. The wheel button also worked well, and wasn't too stiff, unlike some other mice. The wheel also provided a nice ratcheting feedback, and all of the buttons were within easy reach - no contortion needed to reach any of them.

My main complaint would have to be with how sensitivity is changed on the G3. If you only have two sensitivity settings for the G3, the single button isn't a problem, as you'll just be toggling between the two, and chances are, the settings are far enough apart that you won't have trouble telling what the sensitivity is currently set to, just by usage. However, if you have three or more settings, switching becomes tricky and keeping track of what the G3 is currently set to becomes hard because of the lack of an indicator on the G3. Switching between three settings is hard with only one button, as the order goes like this: low->medium->high->medium->low, as mentioned before. There isn't really a good way to switch between three using only one button, though.

My other complaint would be with the side buttons. The button on your thumb-side is easy enough to use, but the other one is a little tricky and takes time to get used to; you might also find yourself accidentally pressing it when holding the mouse. Also, there's a lack of a tilt-wheel for side-to-side scrolling on the G3, which puts it at a disadvantage with other high-end mice, almost all of which feature a tilt wheel.

Conclusion:

I was very impressed by the G3, and it makes a great ambidextrous addition to Logitech's gaming mouse lineup. While it doesn't offer the functionality of its bigger brothers, the G5/G7, it features a more traditional shape that works well in either type of hand. It also remains quite comfortable to use, with the DryGrip sides providing a good hold and feel.

It's also extremely accurate and precise, and the sensitivity switching makes it ideal for gaming or even desktop tasks like image editing. If you're still using a 400 (or even an 800) DPI mouse, moving to the G3 will feel like a huge step up. I'd definitely recommend the G3 Laser Mouse. Many thanks to Logitech for making this review possible.

Pros:

Precise and accurate tracking

Sensitivity adjustments

Comfortable to use

Two extra side buttons

Right or left handed usage

Light weight, low friction

Ideal for gamers

Cons:

Sensitivity switching tricky with only one button

SetPoint installation needed for 2000 DPI

No tilt wheel

Side button opposite thumb can be tricky to use

Editorial Reviews
From the manufacturer
Pure performance and precision.

With Logitech's SetPoint software, you can customize your G3 Laser Mouse with game detection and in-game adjustable sensitivity (including independent x- and y-axis settings).

Full-speed USB at 500 reports/second, for precision at any speed.
2000 dpi gaming-grade laser engine; the highest-performance laser sensor for lightning-fast moves.
Built for long gaming sessions, with its ultra-light design and DryGrip surface.
Precise, fingertip control design; compact, ambidextrous design for quick wrist movements.
Sensitivity switching on-the-fly; one-button instant switching between two sensitivity levels—800 dpi and 1600 dpi—before driver installation.
Polytetrafluoroethylene gaming feet; low-friction feet for a super-smooth glide.

Product Details
Amazon Sales Rank: #2842 in Consumer Electronics
Color: Charcoal
Brand: Logitech
Model: 931691-0403
Released on: 2006-11-17
ESRB Rating: Everyone
Dimensions: 3.00 pounds

Features
Full-speed USB at 500 reports/second delivers precision at any speed
2000 dpi gaming-grade laser engine
Ultra-light design and DryGrip surface
Compact, ambidextrous design for quick wrist movements
On-the-fly sensitivity switching (800 dpi and 1600 dpi)

Logitech Gaming Mouse

Logitech G3 Laser Mouse ( 931691-0403 )